Entry: And it's Hulk. Err… Psycho. No, wait, I think it's Ghajini. Hey! It's Memento. Ummm… Wednesday, December 31, 2008
I suppose you know by now which D O U B L E S P A C E D movie I'm talking
about. If you don't, it's really not your fault. I was pretty confused when I
watched it too. But the film I'm about to review is called Ghajini. (The Hindi
one - just making sure we're on the same page!)
So let's get the riff raff out first. This is a point in Jiah Khan's life
when she most certainly needs to look for another career option. Acting, as is
obvious, is not her cup of tea, at least not in Hindi cinema. (Yes Jiah, we know
you detest movies that involve you dancing around trees, but you could at least
try speaking in Hindi!)
Asin; new to Hindi cinema too, but slightly more promising than Jiah Khan.
So, when Director A. R. Murugadoss tells her about her character, she goes home
and studiously watches Amelie 12 times to try and get the character right. Keep
going Asin, we're sure you'll get there someday! But like I said, she's better
than Jiah, although that's not saying much.
Pradeep Rawat, who plays Ghajini, brings back memories of 80’s
and early 90’s Hindi films where the villain wore copious amounts of gold
jewellery and had no real reason to be the villain. While this may be a very
good thing for a movie like Main Hoon Na or Om Shanit Om, which do not claim to
be serious cinematic experiences, in Ghajini, this is one of the first things
that let’s us down. Although, it must be said that Rawat wasn’t exactly bad at
what he was asked to do.
Aamir Khan. We’ve all known him to be the ‘perfectionist’
and ‘the thinking actor’. But these oft used titles don’t quite fit with this
film. And that, by no means, is a comment on his acting skills. Because yours
truly has also put himself through the Tamil version of the movie that was made
about two years ago, and Aamir certainly lifts this one a few notches. All in
all, Aamir is, well, mind-blowing in this flick.
Let us now come to the one man that can make or break a
movie, the director. Unfortunately, in this case, he’s only helped break the
movie, in irreparable ways. And the reason for this seems to be a lack of
vision in A. R. Murugadoss’s mind. One gets the feeling that he watched Memento
and wanted, as soon as he could, to make his own rendition of it. Turns out he
didn’t quite think things through before going on the floor with Ghajini. If we
just took the movie piece by piece, we’d know why.
To begin with, things have been oversimplified and spelt out
in this film. And in spite of the fact that many would go as far as to call
this a suspense thriller, we already know who Sanjay Singhania (Aamir) is after.
So, that’s that for the suspense quotient of this film.
Also, I just logged no to the internet to do a little
research on Aterograde Amnesia (that’s what Singhania suffers from) and found
that there is absolutely no way in which the patient’s memory span can be
clearly defined. So, instead of ‘he can only remember things for F-I-F-T-E-E-N
minutes’, it could just be ‘he can’t remember things for very long’. That doesn’t
take too much, does it? Moreover, ambiguity is the one premise that every good
suspense thriller rests on, no?
To come to Aamir’s eight-pack-abs. Good job, sir. But why
exactly? I should very much like to know why someone needs to go and build that
kind of a hulky frame when all it needs to blow heads off is a gun! Even if we
leave out this humble blogger’s personal opinion out, what exactly is the
reason for those abs, apart from making great promotional news, of course?
Let us now relate my views to what actually happens in the
movie. Singhania, after having his brains blown out, becomes this all-out
psychotic man, who cannot remember things for too long. So he starts getting
things tattooed on his body. He gets by with a little help from a Polaroid
camera. All understandable so far. And then there’s Murugadoss’s touch.
Singhania starts scribbling violent graffiti on the same wall. Just a little
something to think about here. Already he can’t remember things, and to add to
that, there’s random scribblings on a wall that’s supposed to let him know the
people whose pictures it holds. I’m quite as much as confused as Singhania
should have been.
Now, finally, the biggest problem with this film. The
absolute lack of sensitivity. One can understand that Singhania’s only means to
cool himself off is to kill Ghajini and keep a photograph of the event.
However, there is not a frame where he thinks about Kalpana (Asin) and feels
sad about what happened. Murugadoss seems to have discounted the fact that the biggest
reason for anger is sadness. And although, it’s fair for Singhania to not feel
guilty about killing a few dozen unrelated people, he is not once shown
thinking about it, not even within fifteen minutes of realizing it.
All in all, Ghajini is not particularly a good movie, or even
a highly entertaining one.
3 comments
Meds January 2, 2009 05:03 PM PST I saw Memento yesterday, and it'd be an insult to compare the two. Really. There's nothing similar except that memory loss thingie. Wat a movie that was.
ink and olives January 1, 2009 06:36 PM PST i am telling you. murugadoss is a genius wokkay? there was a shot in this film that the censors objected toand he therefore had to remove it from the movie. apparently it had aamir hitting someone on the stomach with a broken tap and pipe, which managed to get stuck in the evil do-er's stomach. and then...blood started to flow out of the tap!!!!
ahhaaa...mind yitttt!!!
Biprorshee January 1, 2009 06:18 PM PST "...Biggest reason for anger is sadness"...Wonderful!
Now I know why am I so angry watching this mother of a terrible flick!!!!
REMEMBER REVENGE!!!!